THE PALADIN OF THE THIRD
M. Le Chevalier de Chabrillane had been closely connected, you will
remember, with the iniquitous affair in which Philippe de Vilmorin
had lost his life. We know enough to justify a surmise that he had
not merely been La Tour d'Azyr's second in the encounter, but
actually an instigator of the business. Andre-Louis may therefore
have felt a justifiable satisfaction in offering up the Chevalier's
life to the Manes of his murdered friend. He may have viewed it as
an act of common justice not to be procured by any other means.
Also it is to be remembered that Chabrillane had gone confidently
to the meeting, conceiving that he, a practised ferailleur, had to
deal with a bourgeois utterly unskilled in swordsmanship. Morally,
then, he was little better than a murderer, and that he should have
tumbled into the pit he conceived that he dug for Andre-Louis was
a poetic retribution. Yet, notwithstanding all this, I should find
the cynical note on which Andre-Louis announced the issue to the
Assembly utterly detestable did I believe it sincere. It would
justify Aline of the expressed opinion, which she held in common
with so many others who had come into close contact with him, that
Andre-Louis was quite heartless.
You have seen something of the same heartlessness in his conduct
when he discovered the faithlessness of La Binet although that is
belied by the measures he took to avenge himself. His subsequent
contempt of the woman I account to be born of the affection in which
for a time he held her. That this affection was as deep as he first
imagined, I do not believe; but that it was as shallow as he would
almost be at pains to make it appear by the completeness with which
he affects to have put her from his mind when he discovered her
worthlessness, I do not believe; nor, as I have said, do his actions
encourage that belief. Then, again, his callous cynicism in hoping
that he had killed Binet is also an affectation. Knowing that such
things as Binet are better out of the world, he can have suffered
no compunction; he had, you must remember, that rarely level vision
which sees things in their just proportions, and never either
magnifies or reduces them by sentimental considerations. At the
same time, that he should contemplate the taking of life with such
complete and cynical equanimity, whatever the justification, is
Similarly now, it is not to be believed that in coming straight
from the Bois de Boulogne, straight from the killing of a man, he
should be sincerely expressing his nature in alluding to the fact
in terms of such outrageous flippancy. Not quite to such an extent
was he the incarnation of Scaramouche. But sufficiently was he so
ever to mask his true feelings by an arresting gesture, his true
thoughts by an effective phrase. He was the actor always, a man
ever calculating the effect he would produce, ever avoiding
self-revelation, ever concerned to overlay his real character by
an assumed and quite fictitious one. There was in this something
of impishness, and something of other things.
Nobody laughed now at his flippancy. He did not intend that
anybody should. He intended to be terrible; and he knew that the
more flippant and casual his tone, the more terrible would be its
effect. He produced exactly the effect he desired.
What followed in a place where feelings and practices had become
what they had become is not difficult to surmise. When the session
rose, there were a dozen spadassins awaiting him in the vestibule,
and this time the men of his own party were less concerned to guard
him. He seemed so entirely capable of guarding himself; he appeared,
for all his circumspection, to have so completely carried the war
into the enemy's camp, so completely to have adopted their own
methods, that his fellows scarcely felt the need to protect him
As he emerged, he scanned that hostile file, whose air and garments
marked them so clearly for what they were. He paused, seeking the
man he expected, the man he was most anxious to oblige. But M. de
La Tour d'Azyr was absent from those eager ranks. This seemed to
him odd. La Tour d'Azyr was Chabrillane's cousin and closest friend.
Surely he should have been among the first to-day. The fact was
that La Tour d'Azyr was too deeply overcome by amazement and grief
at the utterly unexpected event. Also his vindictiveness was held
curiously in leash. Perhaps he, too, remembered the part played by
Chabrillane in the affair at Gavrillac, and saw in this obscure
Andre-Louis Moreau, who had so persistently persecuted him ever
since, an ordained avenger. The repugnance he felt to come to the
point, with him, particularly after this culminating provocation,
was puzzling even to himself. But it existed, and it curbed him now.
To Andre-Louis, since La Tour was not one of that waiting pack, it
mattered little on that Tuesday morning who should be the next. The
next, as it happened, was the young Vicomte de La Motte-Royau, one
of the deadliest blades in the group.
On the Wednesday morning, coming again an hour or so late to the
Assembly, Andre-Louis announced - in much the same terms as he had
announced the death of Chabrillane - that M. de La Motte-Royau
would probably not disturb the harmony of the Assembly for some
weeks to come, assuming that he were so fortunate as to recover
ultimately from the effects of an unpleasant accident with which he
had quite unexpectedly had the misfortune to meet that morning.
On Thursday he made an identical announcement with regard to the
Vidame de Blavon. On Friday he told them that he had been delayed
by M. de Troiscantins, and then turning to the members of the Cote
Droit, and lengthening his face to a sympathetic gravity:
"I am glad to inform you, messieurs, that M. des Troiscantins is
in the hands of a very competent surgeon who hopes with care to
restore him to your councils in a few weeks' time."
It was paralyzing, fantastic, unreal; and friend and foe in that
assembly sat alike stupefied under those bland daily announcements.
Four of the most redoubtable spadassinicides put away for a time,
one of them dead - and all this performed with such an air of
indifference and announced in such casual terms by a wretched little
He began to assume in their eyes a romantic aspect. Even that group
of philosophers of the Cote Gauche, who refused to worship any force
but the force of reason, began to look upon him with a respect and
consideration which no oratorical triumphs could ever have procured
And from the Assembly the fame of him oozed out gradually over Paris.
Desmoulins wrote a panegyric upon him in his paper "Les Revolutions,"
wherein he dubbed him the "Paladin of the Third Estate," a name that
caught the fancy of the people, and clung to him for some time.
Disdainfully was he mentioned in the "Actes des Apotres," the mocking
organ of the Privileged party, so light-heartedly and provocatively
edited by a group of gentlemen afflicted by a singular mental myopy.
The Friday of that very busy week in the life of this young man who
even thereafter is to persist in reminding us that he is not in any
sense a man of action, found the vestibule of the Manege empty of
swordsmen when he made his leisurely and expectant egress between
Le Chapelier and Kersain.
So surprised was he that he checked in his stride.
"Have they had enough?" he wondered, addressing the question to Le
"They have had enough of you, I should think," was the answer.
"They will prefer to turn their attention to some one less able to
take care of himself."
Now this was disappointing. Andre-Louis had lent himself to this
business with a very definite object in view. The slaying of
Chabrillane had, as far as it went, been satisfactory. He had
regarded that as a sort of acceptable hors d'oeuvre. But the
three who had followed were no affair of his at all. He had met
them with a certain amount of repugnance, and dealt with each as
lightly as consideration of his own safety permitted. Was the
baiting of him now to cease whilst the man at whom he aimed had
not presented himself? In that case it would be necessary to force
Out there under the awning a group of gentlemen stood in earnest
talk. Scanning the group in a rapid glance, Andre-Louis perceived
M. de La Tour d'Azyr amongst them. He tightened his lips. He must
afford no provocation. It must be for them to fasten their quarrels
upon him. Already the "Actes des Apotres" that morning had torn the
mask from his face, and proclaimed him the fencing-master of the Rue
du Hasard, successor to Bertrand des Amis. Hazardous as it had been
hitherto for a man of his condition to engage in single combat it
was rendered doubly so by this exposure, offered to the public as
an aristocratic apologia.
Still, matters could not be left where they were, or he should have
had all his pains for nothing. Carefully looking away from that
group of gentlemen, he raised his voice so that his words must
carry to their ears.
"It begins to look as if my fears of having to spend the remainder
of my days in the Bois were idle."
Out of the corner of his eye he caught the stir his words created
in that group. Its members had turned to look at him; but for the
moment that was all. A little more was necessary. Pacing slowly
along between his friends he resumed:
"But is it not remarkable that the assassin of Lagror should make
no move against Lagron's successor? Or perhaps it is not remarkable.
Perhaps there are good reasons. Perhaps the gentleman is prudent."
He bad passed the group by now, and he left that last sentence of
his to trail behind him, and after it sent laughter, insolent and
He had not long to wait. Came a quick step behind him, and a hand
falling upon his shoulder, spun him violently round. He was brought
face to face with M. de La Tour d'Azyr, whose handsome countenance
was calm and composed, but whose eyes reflected something of the
sudden blaze of passion stirring in him. Behind him several members
of the group were approaching more slowly. The others - like
Andre-Louis' two companions - remained at gaze.
"You spoke of me, I think," said the Marquis quietly. "I spoke of
an assassin - yes. But to these my friends." Andre-Louis' manner
was no less quiet, indeed the quieter of the two, for he was the
more experienced actor.
"You spoke loudly enough to be overheard," said the Marquis,
answering the insinuation that he had been eavesdropping.
"Those who wish to overhear frequently contrive to do so."
"I perceive that it is your aim to be offensive."
"Oh, but you are mistaken, M. le Marquis. I have no wish to be
offensive. But I resent having hands violently laid upon me,
especially when they are hands that I cannot consider clean, In the
circumstances I can hardly be expected to be polite."
The elder man's eyelids flickered. Almost he caught himself
admiring Andre-Louis' bearing. Rather, he feared that his own must
suffer by comparison. Because of this, he enraged altogether, and
lost control of himself.
"You spoke of me as the assassin of Lagron. I do not affect to
misunderstand you. You expounded your views to me once before, and
"But what flattery, monsieur!"
"You called me an assassin then, because I used my skill to dispose
of a turbulent hot-head who made the world unsafe for me. But how
much better are you, M. the fencing-master, when you oppose yourself
to men whose skill is as naturally inferior to your own!"
M. de La Tour d'Azyr's friends looked grave, perturbed. It was
really incredible to find this great gentleman so far forgetting
himself as to descend to argument with a canaille of a
lawyer-swordsman. And what was worse, it was an argument in which
he was being made ridiculous.
"I oppose myself to them!" said Andre-Louis on a tone of amused
protest. "Ah, pardon, M. le Marquis; it is they who chose to oppose
themselves to me - and so stupidly. They push me, they slap my
face, they tread on my toes, they call me by unpleasant names. What
if I am a fencing-master? Must I on that account submit to every
manner of ill-treatment from your bad-mannered friends? Perhaps had
they found out sooner that I am a fencing-master their manners would
have been better. But to blame me for that! What injustice!"
"Comedian!" the Marquis contemptuously apostrophized him. "Does it
alter the case? Are these men who have opposed you men who live by
the sword like yourself?"
"On the contrary, M. le Marquis, I have found them men who died by
the sword with astonishing ease. I cannot suppose that you desire
to add yourself to their number."
"And why, if you please?" La Tour d'Azyr's face had flamed scarlet
before that sneer.
"Oh," Andre-Louis raised his eyebrows and pursed his lips, a man
considering. He delivered himself slowly. "Because, monsieur, you
prefer the easy victim - the Lagrons and Vilmorins of this world,
mere sheep for your butchering. That is why."
And then the Marquis struck him.
Andre-Louis stepped back. His eyes gleamed a moment; the next they
were smiling up into the face of his tall enemy.
"No better than the others, after all! Well, well! Remark, I beg
you, how history repeats itself - with certain differences. Because
poor Vilmorin could not bear a vile lie with which you goaded him,
he struck you. Because you cannot bear an equally vile truth which
I have uttered, you strike me. But always is the vileness yours.
And now as then for the striker there is... " He broke off. "But
why name it? You will remember what there is. Yourself you wrote
it that day with the point of your too-ready sword. But there.
I will meet you if you desire it, monsieur."
"What else do you suppose that I desire? To talk?"
Andre-Louis turned to his friends and sighed. "So that I am to go
another jaunt to the Bois. Isaac, perhaps you will kindly have a
word with one of these friends of M. le Marquis', and arrange for
nine o'clock to-morrow, as usual."
"Not to-morrow," said the Marquis shortly to Le Chapeher. "I have
an engagement in the country, which I cannot postpone."
Le Chapelier looked at Andre-Louis.
"Then for M. le Marquis' convenience, we will say Sunday at the
"I do not fight on Sunday. I am not a pagan to break the holy day."
"But surely the good God would not have the presumption to damn a
gentleman of M. le Marquis' quality on that account? Ah, well,
Isaac, please arrange for Monday, if it is not a feast-day or
monsieur has not some other pressing engagement. I leave it in
He bowed with the air of a man wearied by these details, and
threading his arm through Kersain's withdrew.
"Ah, Dieu de Dieu! But what a trick of it you have," said the
Breton deputy, entirely unsophisticated in these matters.
"To be sure I have. I have taken lessons at their hands." He
laughed. He was in excellent good-humour. And Kersam was
enrolled in the ranks of those who accounted Andre-Louis a man
without heart or conscience.
But in his "Confessions" he tells us - and this is one of the
glimpses that reveal the true man under all that make-believe
- that on that night he went down on his knees to commune with
his dead friend Philippe, and to call his spirit to witness that
he was about to take the last step in the fulfilment of the oath
sworn upon his body at Gavrillac two years ago.